Photo-Safe Scrapbooking Supplies: Acid-Free, Lignin-Free and the PAT
On the table
- pH testing pen for paper
- Acid-free, lignin-free cardstock
- Acid-free double-sided tape or tape runner
- Photo corners, paper or polypropylene
- Polypropylene or polyester page protectors
- Pigment-ink pen labeled archival or fade-resistant
- Polypropylene memorabilia pockets
- Lidded archival box for loose prints
Photos in old albums rarely fail on their own. They fail because of what they were stuck to, slid into or stored beside: a brown cardboard page, a strip of cellophane tape, a vinyl sleeve, a folded newspaper clipping. The supplies on the shelf today are far better, but the labels on them range from tightly defined to meaningless, and it pays to know which is which.
What the labels on the package mean
| Label | What it means | What it does not promise |
|---|---|---|
| Acid-free | pH of 7 or higher at manufacture | That it stays neutral if it contains lignin or touches acidic material |
| Buffered | Contains an alkaline reserve, usually calcium carbonate, that neutralizes acid moving in from outside | That it suits every photo: cyanotypes and some older prints are better kept in unbuffered enclosures |
| Lignin-free | Lignin, the wood component that browns newsprint, has been removed | Anything about the pH on its own |
| PAT passed | Passed the Photographic Activity Test (ISO 18916), which checks whether a material stains or fades photographic images in contact with it | A lifetime guarantee for the finished page |
| Photo-safe | A marketing term with no single standard | Anything, unless backed by a PAT result |
| Archival | No fixed definition | Anything, on its own |
The PAT is the label that matters most for anything touching a print. It is run by testing laboratories, best known among them the Image Permanence Institute at Rochester Institute of Technology, and a manufacturer that has passed it usually says so on the package. Acid-free plus lignin-free covers cardstock and patterned paper; adhesives, sleeves and pens that sit against a photo should carry the PAT on top.
Testing what you already own
A pH testing pen tells you whether a paper is acidic. Draw a short line on a corner that will not show, then compare the color to the chart on the pen. The common pens use chlorophenol red, which stays purple on acid-free paper and turns yellow or clear on acidic paper; brands differ, so go by the chart supplied with yours.
The pen tests pH only. It cannot detect lignin, and it says nothing about adhesives or inks. Lignin is the slower problem. A paper can test neutral on the day you buy it and still turn yellow and acidic over the following years, because lignin breaks down with light and air; newsprint left on a sunny windowsill shows the process within days. That is the reason the two labels belong together: acid-free describes the paper now, lignin-free describes how it will age. Test new paper on arrival, old patterned paper of unknown origin before it goes near a photo, and anything with a bargain-bin feel, such as kraft cardstock without a label.
Adhesives that hold without staining
| Adhesive | Use it for | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Acid-free tape runner | Photos, mats, paper layers | Holds flat; check for a PAT mark if it touches prints |
| Photo corners | Prints you may want to remove later | The print is never glued at all |
| Glue dots | Buttons, flowers, small embellishments | Keep off the face of a photo |
| pH-neutral liquid glue | Die cuts, small paper pieces | Use sparingly; too much buckles thin paper |
| Foam squares | Lifting a layer | Raised pieces press into facing pages |
Rubber cement, household cellophane tape and masking tape do not belong on a scrapbook page. Rubber cement stains and lets go; cellophane and masking tape yellow, dry out and drop the photo while leaving a brown stripe behind. Photo corners are the safest choice for a one-of-a-kind print, since nothing touches its back.
Sleeves, protectors and memorabilia
Polypropylene, polyester and polyethylene are stable plastics and are safe around photos. PVC, sold as vinyl, releases chemicals as it ages that damage prints and can leave a sticky film on them. Page protectors sold in the scrapbooking aisle today are almost always polypropylene, and the package says so. Older binders and sheet protectors from an office supply drawer are worth checking before they get a photo.
Memorabilia brings its own trouble:
- Newspaper clippings are acidic and high in lignin. Photocopy or scan them onto acid-free paper, or treat the original with a deacidification spray and keep it in its own sleeve.
- Thermal receipts and tickets fade, sometimes within a few years. Scan them and print the scan.
- Fabric, pressed flowers and sand go into a sealed polypropylene pocket, away from direct contact with a print.
Children’s artwork on construction paper is a quieter version of the same problem. Construction paper is usually acidic and fades fast in light, so a drawing worth keeping is better photographed and printed at the size of a pocket, with the original stored flat in a folder of its own.
The best rule for memorabilia is distance. A clipping two pages away from the nearest photo is far less of a risk than one mounted on the same mat.
Inks, pens and embellishments
Pigment ink holds up better to light than dye ink, and a pigment fineliner is the safe choice for journaling and for stamped dates. The guide to stamp inks explains the difference between pigment and dye in more detail. Metal embellishments such as brads and eyelets can tarnish; keep them off the face of a photo. Loose glitter scratches prints, so seal it with a glaze or keep it on a separate page.
Thick embellishments are a physical risk, too. A chipboard shape on one page presses into the photo opposite it every time the album closes, and over months that leaves a dent. When planning page layouts, keep raised pieces away from photos on the facing page. In a pocket album the same applies to anything stuck onto a card; the pocket page guide keeps embellishments flat for that reason. The rest of the craft is on the scrapbooking hub.
Where the album lives
Heat, humidity and light do more harm than any adhesive. Keep albums in a living space that stays below roughly 75°F with relative humidity around 30 to 50 percent, away from exterior walls, radiators and windows. Attics bake in summer, basements stay damp, and both swing widely between seasons, which is the worst condition of all for prints. Loose photos waiting for an album belong in a lidded box made for photographs, standing upright in their envelopes.
Shelve finished albums upright like books, with enough space around them that they do not lean. An album laid flat at the bottom of a stack carries the weight of every album above it, and that pressure lands on every embellishment inside.
Questions crafters ask
Is acid-free paper the same as archival paper?
No. Acid-free means a pH of 7 or higher when the paper was made. Archival has no fixed definition, so look for acid-free and lignin-free together, and a passed PAT for anything that touches a photo.
Are old magnetic photo albums bad for photos?
Yes. The adhesive on those pages yellows and grips prints harder with age, and many of the cover sheets are PVC. Slide unwaxed dental floss behind a print to lift it, and scan any print that will not release.
How can I tell whether a page protector is PVC?
Check the packaging for polypropylene, polyester or polyethylene, all of which are safe. A sleeve with no material listed, a strong plastic smell or a slightly tacky feel is likely vinyl and should not hold photos.
Can I use ordinary printer paper for journaling?
Test it with a pH pen first. Many office papers test acid-free, but cardstock sold as acid-free and lignin-free removes the guesswork.
More in Scrapbooking Ideas for Beginners, With Page Layouts, Journaling and Photo-Safe Albums