Colored Pencils on Stamped Images: Layering, Burnishing and Blending
On the table
- Colored pencils, 24-36 colors, wax- or oil-based
- Vellum-finish Bristol or cardstock with some tooth
- Kraft cardstock and a white pencil for highlights
- Colorless blender pencil
- Odorless mineral spirits in a small lidded jar
- Paper blending stumps (tortillons)
- Handheld sharpener and a kneaded eraser
- Gray or brown stamping ink for softer outlines
Colored pencil is the slowest way to color a stamped image and the most forgiving one. Nothing bleeds. Nothing dries before you are ready, and a patch that went too dark can be partly lifted with a kneaded eraser. The price is time: even a small flower needs many light layers before it looks smooth, and rushing those layers is what makes pencil work look like a child’s drawing.
Of the four media compared on the coloring hub, pencil is also the only one that works on brown and colored cardstock.
Wax or oil: what changes in your hand
| Property | Wax-based pencils | Oil-based pencils |
|---|---|---|
| Core | Soft and creamy | Firmer |
| Point | Wears down quickly, frequent sharpening | Holds a sharp point for fine lines |
| Layering | Fills the paper texture fast, fewer layers | More layers before the paper is saturated |
| Blending | Blends readily under pressure | Blends with solvent or patient layering |
| Wax bloom | Yes, on heavy layers | No |
| Tiny details (eyes, whiskers) | Harder | Easier |
Both work on stamped images. Wax pencils suit kraft cards and quick, saturated coloring. Oil pencils suit small, intricate stamps where a needle-sharp point matters. Plenty of colorists own a wax set and add a handful of oil pencils in black, dark brown and white for details.
Paper with tooth
Tooth is the fine texture of a paper surface. Pencil pigment catches on the high points, and each layer fills a little more of the low points until the surface turns slick and refuses more color.
Smooth cardstock made for alcohol markers has very little tooth, so pencil stops building after a couple of passes. Vellum-finish Bristol, most standard cardstock and kraft give far more room. A sheet with too much texture has the opposite problem: white specks stay visible however much you layer.
In an art journal, a coat of gesso gives tooth to a page that would otherwise repel pencil; gesso and texture paste covers priming a surface that way.
Stamping for pencil work
Any ink will do once it is dry, pigment ink included. A heavy black outline fights soft pencil shading, though, so many colorists stamp in gray or brown and let the shading define the edges.
Planning to blend with solvent? Test the stamped line first. Dab a little mineral spirits on a stamped scrap and watch whether the line moves. Solvent-based stamping inks will.
Layering from light pressure up
Pressure is the main control in pencil work. Think in four steps: barely touching, light, medium and heavy. Almost everything below happens at the first two.
- Map the shadows with a pale gray or a light version of the shadow color, barely touching the paper.
- Cover the whole shape with the lightest color in small overlapping circles.
- Build the middle and dark values on the shadow side, still at light pressure, in several thin layers.
- Bridge each boundary between two values with the lighter of the two colors.
- Finish with burnishing or solvent, never both on the same area.
Shadows look more natural in a darker, cooler neighbor of the base color than in black or gray. A red apple shades with a deep red-violet, a yellow flower with ochre or a soft orange. Black pencil flattens everything it touches and looks dirty once a few layers sit over it.
A kneaded eraser lifts pencil by pressing, not rubbing. Shape it to a point, press it onto the spot that went too dark and lift; rubbing smears the pigment and wears down the paper’s tooth.
Small circular strokes hide pencil marks; back-and-forth lines leave visible stripes. Fur, feathers and grass are the exception, where short strokes following the direction of growth do the describing for you.
Burnishing: the last layer, never a middle one
Burnishing means pressing hard enough to flatten the pigment and fill whatever tooth is left. The surface goes smooth, almost painted, and the color deepens. A colorless blender pencil does it without changing the hue; a white pencil burnishes and lightens at once; the lightest color in the area works too.
Once burnished, the paper accepts very little more pencil. Burnish only when the shading is finished, and if one corner still needs a dark accent, add it before you burnish the rest.
Solvent blending
Odorless mineral spirits dissolve the binder in the pencil core and let the pigment flow, turning a grainy layer into something close to a wash. Dip a paper stump or a small brush, blot it on a towel, and work it over the colored area in the same direction as the shading. Clean the stump on scrap before moving from a dark area into a light one.
Work in a ventilated room and keep the jar lidded between dips. Let the blended area dry until it looks matte again before adding pencil on top.
Pencil also sits well over a dry marker base, which is a common way to finish realistic images: smooth color from alcohol markers first, then texture and crisp detail in pencil.
Kraft and colored cardstock
On kraft, every color goes on darker than it would on white, because the brown shows through. Lay a white pencil base under pale colors so they keep their hue, then finish highlights in white at heavy pressure. They glow against the brown in a way no marker can match.
Gray cardstock does the same job for winter scenes, with white and a pale blue doing most of the work. Black cardstock is possible too, but only with opaque, soft pencils and a lot of patience.
Sharpen soft wax pencils with a handheld sharpener and stop as soon as the point forms. A long, needle-thin point on a soft core snaps at the first bit of pressure.
Questions crafters ask
What is the white haze on my wax pencil coloring?
Wax bloom, the binder rising to the surface where layers are heavy. Wipe it gently with a soft tissue; it can return, and a spray fixative stops it for good.
Can I add colored pencil over alcohol markers?
Yes, once the marker is dry. Marker cardstock is smooth, though, so the pencil only builds for a layer or two; keep it for shading and texture.
Is baby oil a good blending solvent?
It blends, but it never fully evaporates and can leave the paper greasy and translucent over time. Odorless mineral spirits dry out completely.
Why does my pencil coloring look grainy?
White paper is showing through in the low points of the paper texture. Add more light layers, then burnish or blend with solvent to push pigment into those gaps.
More in Coloring Stamped Images: Marker, Pencil and Watercolor Techniques